-
Why paying off a collection could hurt your credit score
March 19, 2024
Minneapolis, MN: When looking to buy a home, we all know having good credit scores helps a lot. Both in just the ability to even get a loan, and to get the best possible interest rate on the mortgage.
To that end, many people correctly trying cleaning up anything old and negative on their credit report. I recently had a client reach out to me who a month ago, paid off about a 5-year old small collection on their credit report that was less than $100 expecting that doing so would improve her credit scores.
To her amazement, when I pulled her credit report for her mortgage application, her scores was LOWER! She wondered why paying off a collection HURT her credit score, not helped.
The major issue here is that ANYTIME there is any activity on an account, including a payment, it will update the ‘date of last activity’ or DLA. So in this case, the small, and 5-year old unpaid collection on her credit, which was only hurting her score a little bit because of how old it was, now moved the negative activity date to current, and a current collection, even paid, will easily drop a score 30-points or more.
Worse yet, it also resets the negative information to another 7-years BEFORE it falls off her credit report. Yikes!
What Should You Do About Collections on Your Credit Report?
That depends. A current unpaid collection hurts your credit score a lot. A paid collection hurts less.
The first tip is to reach out to the creditor and do everything you can to totally get it deleted and removed. Many creditors are willing to removing it upon payment. Try that.
If it is a fairly recent collection, which is roughly less than two-years old, you should pay it off.
If it is more than two-years old, and especially if it is 4-yr or more old, in more cases than not, it is probably best to avoid paying off the collection as it will hurt your credit score in the short-term and keep in on your credit report for another full seven years.
Share via: